BRETT HALL
  • Home
  • Physics
    • An anthropic universe?
    • Temperature and Heat
    • Light
    • General Relativity and the Role of Evidence
    • Gravity is not a force
    • Rare Earth biogenesis
    • Fine Structure
    • Errors and Uncertainties
    • The Multiverse
    • Galaxy Collisions
    • Olber's Paradox
  • About
  • ToKCast
    • Episode 100
    • Ep 111: Probability >
      • Probability Transcript
  • Blog
    • Draft Script
  • Philosophy
    • Epistemology
    • Fallibilism
    • Bayesian "Epistemology"
    • The Aim of Science
    • Physics and Learning Styles
    • Science and Values
    • Descartes' Meditations
    • Positive Philosophy >
      • Positive Philosophy 2
      • Positive Philosophy 3
      • Positive Philosophy 4
    • Inexplicit Knowledge
    • Philosophers on the Web
    • David Deutsch & Sam Harris
    • David Deutsch: Mysticism and Quantum Theory
    • Morality
    • Free Will
    • Humans and Other Animals
    • Principles and Practises: Preface >
      • Part 2: Modelling Reality
      • Part 3: Political Principles and Practice
      • Part 4: Ideals in Politics
      • Part 5: The Fundamental Conflict
    • Superintelligence >
      • Superintelligence 2
      • Superintelligence 3
      • Superintelligence 4
      • Superintelligence 5
      • Superintelligence 6
  • Korean Sydney
  • Other
    • Critical and Creative Thinking >
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 2
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 3
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 4
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 5
    • Learning >
      • Part 2: Epistemology and Compulsory School
      • Part 3: To learn you must be able to choose
      • Part 4: But don't you need to know how to read?
      • Part 5: Expert Children
      • Part 6: But we need scientific literacy, don't we?
      • Part 7: Towards Voluntary Schools
    • Cosmological Economics
    • The Moral Landscape Challenge
    • Schools of Hellas
  • Postive Philosophy blog
  • Alien Intelligence
  • High Finance
  • New Page
  • Serendipity In Science
  • Philosophy of Science
  • My YouTube Channel
  • The Nature of Philosophical Problems
  • The Nature of Philosophical Problems with Commentary
  • Subjective Knowledge
  • Free Will, consciousness, creativity, explanations, knowledge and choice.
    • Creativity and Consciousness
  • Solipsism
  • P
  • Image for Podcast
  • ToK Introduction
  • Begging the Big Ones
  • Blog
  • Our Most Important Problems
  • Corona Podcasts
    • Brendan and Peter
    • Jonathan Davis
  • Responses
  • Audio Responses
  • New Page
  • Critically Creative 1
  • Critically Creative 2
  • Critically Creative 3
  • Critically Creative 4
  • Critically Creative 5
  • David Deutsch Interview in German
  • Audio Files
  • Lookouts
  • Breakthrough!
  • Quantum Computing Algorithms - Proofs1
  • Learning Deep Learning 101
  • Decision Making
  • Blog
  • Popper and Legal Science

Part 5: Expert Children

I have yet to encounter a child in a support class who is not absolutely expert - for their age - at something. Sometimes they are expert at some academic subject. More often though they are expert at the things of great interest to them: some popular music style, a computer game genre, some series of books or a particular author. I remember a boy who was in the support class for english and mathematics and science. He was universally regarded as in need of extra special help - his literacy was poor. His numeracy was worse. He didn’t particularly seem to care about any of this mind you - it was obvious he didn’t want to be at school. And yet - speak to him for a moment and you realized his mind was as sharp, quick and expert as anyone else’s. He just wasn’t interested in what most people were interested in.

Let’s call him John. John would probably get stigmatized with a label in any school. Educators would say he is on a spectrum somewhere (Autism, most likely). But in truth, John was just a person who had the strength not to bend to the wills of the adults and others around him who wanted him to learn this or that. He didn’t want to. What he wanted? To be involved in Rugby League Football. Not necessarily as a player: but something. And he knew just about everything. John knew the players - their names and match statistics. He had theories on who should be in or out of this or that team (of course, the lesson I wanted to give him was that he should broaden his sources beyond just the News Limited Press, but that’s another story). The point is: he had expertise. He had interests. He could read adequately. He read the sports pages well enough and he seemed to know that getting better at reading would help him learn more about footy, faster and perhaps help him get a job around his favorite sport. He also seemed to understand that all those numbers like: average number of penalties and tries and goals - a broader appreciation of some basic maths would deepen his knowledge of all that. He understood. He was working on it.

But school got in the way of his learning. Instead of allowing him to study rugby league and all the associated knowledge he needed to become an even better expert in that subject they stopped him from learning. And forced him to attend lessons.

                                                                    “I have never let my schooling interfere with my education” - Mark Twain.

So here was the school - like any school - “doing their best for him” by forcing him to attend lessons on the chemistry of water, the physics of electricity, the mathematics of algebra, the English of Some-Book-He-Hated-Reading. All completely useless stuff to him. Trying to indoctrinate him with what his betters deemed important for him to know. But they didn’t know. They weren’t better. He knew. He knew what he needed to learn to do what he wanted.

Only during his holidays and once he finally left school for good - did John have the time to really devote to properly learning  rather than attempts at being educated. He could then pursue a career in the field he was passionate about.

If only he was allowed to do that full time from the moment he realised what he wanted to do. Instead his development was stunted and frustrated by all the adults in his life, enacting cultural memes they never critically analysed.

The student of my story could not be prevented from learning all there was to know about Rugby League. Nor could he be forced to learn lessons he did not want to. He graduated from school never learning much at all about electricity and algebra and who cares? Why should he? Why should we? Let’s admit it: for most people, most of the time - those things do not matter. They can fully participate in the political process, in decision making - in society without knowing those things just as I can without knowing details about how Picasso chose lighting and colour for his Rose Period. And when knowledge of those things become important we can enlist the help of experts. The electrician. The mathematician.

But don't we need an informed electorate? Don't we need scientific literacy? Part 6

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Physics
    • An anthropic universe?
    • Temperature and Heat
    • Light
    • General Relativity and the Role of Evidence
    • Gravity is not a force
    • Rare Earth biogenesis
    • Fine Structure
    • Errors and Uncertainties
    • The Multiverse
    • Galaxy Collisions
    • Olber's Paradox
  • About
  • ToKCast
    • Episode 100
    • Ep 111: Probability >
      • Probability Transcript
  • Blog
    • Draft Script
  • Philosophy
    • Epistemology
    • Fallibilism
    • Bayesian "Epistemology"
    • The Aim of Science
    • Physics and Learning Styles
    • Science and Values
    • Descartes' Meditations
    • Positive Philosophy >
      • Positive Philosophy 2
      • Positive Philosophy 3
      • Positive Philosophy 4
    • Inexplicit Knowledge
    • Philosophers on the Web
    • David Deutsch & Sam Harris
    • David Deutsch: Mysticism and Quantum Theory
    • Morality
    • Free Will
    • Humans and Other Animals
    • Principles and Practises: Preface >
      • Part 2: Modelling Reality
      • Part 3: Political Principles and Practice
      • Part 4: Ideals in Politics
      • Part 5: The Fundamental Conflict
    • Superintelligence >
      • Superintelligence 2
      • Superintelligence 3
      • Superintelligence 4
      • Superintelligence 5
      • Superintelligence 6
  • Korean Sydney
  • Other
    • Critical and Creative Thinking >
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 2
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 3
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 4
      • Critical and Creative Thinking 5
    • Learning >
      • Part 2: Epistemology and Compulsory School
      • Part 3: To learn you must be able to choose
      • Part 4: But don't you need to know how to read?
      • Part 5: Expert Children
      • Part 6: But we need scientific literacy, don't we?
      • Part 7: Towards Voluntary Schools
    • Cosmological Economics
    • The Moral Landscape Challenge
    • Schools of Hellas
  • Postive Philosophy blog
  • Alien Intelligence
  • High Finance
  • New Page
  • Serendipity In Science
  • Philosophy of Science
  • My YouTube Channel
  • The Nature of Philosophical Problems
  • The Nature of Philosophical Problems with Commentary
  • Subjective Knowledge
  • Free Will, consciousness, creativity, explanations, knowledge and choice.
    • Creativity and Consciousness
  • Solipsism
  • P
  • Image for Podcast
  • ToK Introduction
  • Begging the Big Ones
  • Blog
  • Our Most Important Problems
  • Corona Podcasts
    • Brendan and Peter
    • Jonathan Davis
  • Responses
  • Audio Responses
  • New Page
  • Critically Creative 1
  • Critically Creative 2
  • Critically Creative 3
  • Critically Creative 4
  • Critically Creative 5
  • David Deutsch Interview in German
  • Audio Files
  • Lookouts
  • Breakthrough!
  • Quantum Computing Algorithms - Proofs1
  • Learning Deep Learning 101
  • Decision Making
  • Blog
  • Popper and Legal Science